44 S. Main Street
Johnstown, OH 43031
OH License #416327
About
Share
Krista Mathers
Real Estate Professional
David Caraboolad
Real Estate Professional
Vadim Barash
Real Estate Professional
Kim Schleder
Real Estate Professional
Mallory Henson
Real Estate Professional
MK
Monica Kagey
recommends
Krista Mathers
Jun 10, 2026
Krista has helped our family with multiple real estate transactions over the years including selling my mother’s house, listing two of our homes, and helping us find and purchase our dream lake house. She is knowledgeable, professional, responsive, and fun! We always felt like her first priority and her candor and grit resulted in us feeling protected and informed at every step of the process. Could not recommend Krista more!!
WA
Winnie and Gary Gerhardt
recommend
David Caraboolad
May 12, 2026
We are extremely happy that we connected with David Caraboolad by recommendation of the realtor helping us sell our current home of nearly 40 years. Needless to say, we had not been in the market to purchase a home for many years and David guided us with professionalism, respect and tremendous communications from our first conversation through closing and beyond. David listened carefully to what we wanted and needed in a condo, and encouraged us to take our time in this process and not compromise on what we wanted. Together we found a beautiful condo in an established development with lots of trees, landscaping and walking paths nearby. David’s knowledge of the Columbus market and his priority to guide us to communities near family were so very appreciated. He negotiated a fair and significantly lower price for our new home and has connected us with reputable, skilled professionals he has worked with for renovations. David has outstanding integrity, he is highly personable, instills trust quickly and consistently, and he delivers. He has our highest recommendation.
DB
Working with Dave was a great experience from start to finish. He helped me sell my condo quickly and handled everything in a professional and organized way. He was responsive and did a great job explaining the process so I always felt confident in the decisions being made. It was clear that he genuinely had my best interest in mind and was focused on getting the best outcome for me. I'd highly recommend Dave to anyone looking for a strong, trustworthy agent.
RD
We highly recommend Dave for anyone looking to purchase a home. His communication throughout the entire process was exceptional; we never had to wonder where we stood or what the next steps were. Above all, Dave operates with true integrity, always putting our interests first and providing honest, candid advice. He went above and beyond by sharing a wealth of transitional resources—from reliable contractors to local utility guides—that we know will help make our move seamless. Dave was a true partner in our home-buying journey.
BK
Bill & Kim S
recommend
David Caraboolad
Nov 22, 2025
Dave is a stellar agent who pays attention to every detail - he has great repport with other agents involved in the transaction and figures out a way to work with everyone to close the deal.
We are glad he was on our side and had all the confidence that he would represent us and guide us in the right direction.
Professionalism through and through.
Thank you Dave!!
We are glad he was on our side and had all the confidence that he would represent us and guide us in the right direction.
Professionalism through and through.
Thank you Dave!!
KK
Kyndall Kegler
recommends
Krista Mathers
Aug 29, 2025
Choosing Krista as our realtor was the best choice ! She worked her butt off for us to be able to get our dream home. She is on top of her game, so knowledgeable and effective in finding what works for you !
TK
Tara Krotzer
recommends
Krista Mathers
Aug 15, 2025
I’ve been in real estate for over 20 years, and I’ve never seen anyone give more to their clients than Krista. Her dedication doesn’t end when the deal closes—she remains just as responsive and supportive afterward, which is a true rarity in this business.
KK
Our realtor was absolutely fantastic in helping us sell our home. She was professional, knowledgeable, and always available to answer our questions. From listing to closing, she guided us every step with ease and made the process stress-free. We couldn’t ask for a better experience and I highly recommend her!!
BK
Dave Caraboolad made selling my parent's home a breeze during a very difficult time in my family's life. He was extremely kind, respectful and patient during the entire process. His professionalism speaks for itself. He sold our property quickly and above list price. I would recommend Dave Caraboolad to anyone wanting to sell a home in Columbus, OH.
CL
Chris Laux
recommends
David Caraboolad
Nov 18, 2024
David was able to help us navigate the challenges of selling a home with care and professionalism. He was able to find the right buyer for our situation and kept us informed every step of the way. Highly Recommend!
M
Marc
recommends
David Caraboolad
Apr 30, 2024
Dave is a pro and did an excellent job of selling the home of a deceased family member. His work set our family at easy by making the selling process easy and finding the right buyer very quickly.
GE
Gabrielle Edwards
recommends
Krista Mathers
Mar 4, 2024
We loved Krista! She made the home buying process so easy! She explained everything so well so my husband and I understood what was happening. If you’re looking to buy a home, Krista is your girl!
PB
Krista did great with the sale of our vintage property in Ohio. We would give her a 6 star rating if it went above a 5 star rating! Thanks so much to her extra efforts.
SC
Shelly Callender
recommends
Krista Mathers
Jan 22, 2024
Krista did an amazing job working with my family to sell our property. Working with out of state clients can be a challenge and she was on top of everything! Great communication and quick sale!
DW
Deborah Wilson
recommends
Krista Mathers
Nov 14, 2023
Krista Mathers definitely gets a 5 star rating in my book. Very thorough , knowledgeable and compassionate about her work. Made selling my house a breeze. I would highly recommend Krista . Thank you for the wonderful opportunity to work with you.
RB
Ronni Boehm
recommends
Krista Mathers
May 22, 2023
Krista helped us sell our home fast and above asking price. She is super friendly and very professional. She makes recommendations that help with the sale of the property. My daughter also used Krista to sell her home with the same results. I highly recommend her and if we ever need to sell our home in the future we would definitely use Krista.
MJ
Michael Jones
recommends
Individual Users 1
Engineering
Feb 15, 2023
Nathan went above and beyond our expectations. We are very thankful for his expertise and patience during the process of purchasing our first home. Thank you Nathan!
JS
Jeffrey stiles
recommends
Krista Mathers
Sep 14, 2022
I would recommend Krista to anybody looking to buy or sell. She has an incredible knack for making miracles happen! With her knowledge and resources she was able to get me in the home I would have never thought possible. Very, very, very good at what she does!!!
JS
Jeff Stilez
recommends
Krista Mathers
Sep 12, 2022
I can’t recommend Krista enough. Very easy scheduling to see properties, most that day or next. She was great helping us find a lender for self-employed, which was a challenge. She is very knowledgeable about the whole process which made it easier for us. Thank you Krista
MR
Melissa Rubadue
recommends
Krista Mathers
Aug 27, 2022
Krista was amazing! She's extremely knowledgeable and does whatever she can to help find the perfect house. Krista made the home search and buying process so much easier even during a time when buying a house seemed impossible. I definitely plan to use her if/or when we decide to buy again.
TW
Krista is an exceptional realtor! She is very professional, considerate, and makes the buying/selling process as easy and painless as possible. She has a tremendous amount of knowledge that she brings to the table, ensuring will get the best price for your home as well as a fair price on your purchase. I highly recommend her for your next real estate purchase/home sale. She’s not just a business professional, but she will also become a friend!
JW
Krista is an exceptional realtor who is experienced, knowledgeable and accessible. Thanks to her expertise and extensive marketing, we were able to sell our home quickly and well above list price. She made the entire home sale process low stress and easy. I would highly recommend her for your home buying and selling needs!
MW
Myranda Watkins
recommends
Krista Mathers
Nov 5, 2021
Krista went above and beyond to get us in our first home. She is very professional and knows her stuff! I would recommend her to anyone and everyone!
DM
If I could give higher than a 5 star rating I would. Krista went above and beyond for my husband and I, and our first time buying a house. As first time home buyers we were nervous and weren’t really sure how the whole process would go but having Krista help us made this experience very pleasant (and in today’s market was a hard task!) She was super flexible with our schedules and lack of knowledge and really helped give us all the information we needed to not only find our perfect house but make sure that we were investing into a property that would actually be a good one for us and our future and not just any house. After working with her once you can tell she is very dedicated to each and every client she had and their specific needs. We will definitely be reaching out to her for every house buying process we have in the future!
AP
Allison Potteiger
recommends
Krista Mathers
Aug 17, 2021
Krista was so helpful in listing my late father’s property and walking us through the process. We were grateful for her help and expertise through the whole process. Thank you Krista and NextHome.
