NextHome Success

913 Madison Ave.
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
WI License #48218-90


Recommendations (189)

Jul 2, 2024

Ben Stoll recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne was always working for us to find the perfect house. He is very knowledgeable on the entire process of purchasing a home and able to answer any question I had along the way. I would recommend Tremayne to anybody looking to buy a house, especially first time homebuyers.
Jun 29, 2024

Tammy DeLosh recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz and her team were wonderful to work with. She was very professional and informative. She walked us through the process of selling our house in today's market and explained the process and timeline very well. She kept in contact with us through the whole process and she was very quick to respond to our e-mails/calls/texts. We would strongly recommend her for any and all you real estate needs. Thanks again Liz and team for the awesome experience!
May 1, 2024

Angel Yang recommends Tonya Toth

Tonya was great! She answered all our questions and was quick to reply; even after office hours. She made us feel comfortable and made the process easier. Highly recommend her!
Apr 27, 2024

Ryan Nelson recommends Dee Dee Haugen Carothers


Dee Dee was very helpful in everything we needed. We had so many questions about buying and selling a home, and she was so helpful and knowledgeable. She was very patient and friendly with us and was a pleasure to work with.
Apr 24, 2024

Karen Kudick recommends Allisia Turner

Great personality, answers questions right away. Works very well with the seller. Super fast sale. Would recommend her as everybody’s realtor person. Thanks so much for all your hard work.
Apr 11, 2024

Laura Hoffman recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne was great to work with. He scheduled showings quickly so that I wouldn’t miss any opportunities to buy my new home. He was willing to view homes during times that worked best for me. He was always quick to reply to any questions I needed answered. He was very responsive to text and phone calls! I was beyond grateful and happy with the help he provided in finding my new home!
Apr 8, 2024

Wes Johnson recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz was amazing!!!! She had our house sold in under a week for above asking price! What more can you ask for than that!!!

Feb 22, 2024

Sarah Thompson recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz is just an amazing person all around and excels as a realtor. She makes buying a home effortless and is extremely knowledgeable in all things home related. She is kind and helpful and quick to respond. She's very good at listening to questions and concerns and makes sure you understand things. I appreciate how she never pressured me to make a decision and allowed me to set the pace. If I ever need to buy and/or sell again, Liz will be my go-to realtor. She truly is someone who you can trust and wants the best for you.
Feb 22, 2024

Michael Smith recommends Allisia Turner


About 2-years ago, Allisia assisted in the selling of my home in Whitewater. Reflecting back, it was such an enjoyable and stress free experience!

I would not hesitate to work with Allisia and highly recommend her to anyone whose considering buying or selling a home in the area.
Feb 13, 2024

Keith Hagen recommends Carolyn Fox

Carolyn worked for me for over three months covering four counties while I was house hunting. I had a very specific and long want list and any house she recommended had at least three of the key elements I was looking for. Her knowledge of the real estate markets in all of my target area was excellent, wide and deep. As well, her knowledge of the ins and outs of real estate contracts was unsurpassed.You will rarely have to wait long for an answer to the most trivial of questions! Made for an eased mind in what can be a difficult process. In my life I have experience with nine different agents and agencies and Carolyn Fox is by far the very best representation I have ever worked with. I have paid out a lot of money in commissions to agents over the years. Carolyn is not even close to the most expensive of them. She is worth every penny.
Jan 29, 2024

Barbara Miles recommends Tonya Toth

Was great to work with, made the entire process quick and simple!
Jan 29, 2024

Krystal McDermott recommends Allisia Turner

Allisia went above and beyond in helping us find our first home!! She made our buying process so smooth and did a wonderful job of explaining the process to us. She found our home for us and worked quickly and tirelessly to submit our offer. She made something that is stressful and overwhelming much easier. I cannot say enough great things about her!! Thank you again Allisia!
Jan 25, 2024

Katie Varela recommends Tonya Toth

Great service and very helpful ! And great at explaining what you need to know & quick response!!! 100% recommend contracting Tonya Toth :)
Jan 1, 2024

Emily Gray recommends Tonya Toth

Tonya did exactly what I asked her to do. Show me houses until I found one. Every step we took together in my home buying journey was excellent. She booked showings when I wanted. She was very prompt with responding to all correspondence. I never had to wait or wonder what was happening. She was very direct with me which I loved. If she didn’t know something she asked more senior coworkers and she still got me the answers I needed in record time. She went over the home inspection with me. I closed within 30 days and she made sure I met all my deadlines as to not prolong the process. I had a wonderful experience with Tonya.
Dec 4, 2023

Joe Van Hecke recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne is awesome! He always replied promptly, set up showings quickly, was very knowledgeable, and an overall pleasure to work with. I would absolutely recommend to anyone.
Nov 30, 2023

Rachel Finger recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tattoo artist

Tremayne was a pleasure to work with. He was very communicative throughout the process and his sense of humor made our first home purchase much less stressful than it could have been! He really knows his stuff and I would recommend him to anyone!
Nov 24, 2023

Mary J Carter recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne helped us sell a home at the price we were hoping to get. Very personable. He was always available to take phone calls and explained everything we needed to do when completing and signing documents. He even helped us move personal property out of the home to be ready in time to be at closing. He was everything we could hope for in a realtor. We highly recommend him.
Nov 10, 2023

Angela Abel recommends Rachel Lehmann

Rachel did an AMAZING job selling my house! I can't thank her enough for answering all my questions and guiding me through the whole process with ease. Her knowledge and expertise is stellar, plus she's so reassuring and just a delight to work with. I highly recommend Rachel for all your real estate needs! Thank you!
Oct 24, 2023

Karen Streuly recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne went above and beyond for us. He is very easy to talk to and has a keen sense of what his prospective buyers are looking for. He found the perfect house for us very quickly, and was available for any questions throughout the process.

Very happy!
Oct 14, 2023

Judy Anderson recommends Liz Kostroski

Working with Liz was wonderful She worked with us on selling and buying a house. She kept us informed of every step and was there every time we called or texted. Ready to show us a house or answer a question at a moment’s notice. This is the second time I have worked with Liz and she will always be my family’s realtor.
Aug 29, 2023

Brett Launderville recommends Tonya Toth

She was absolutely amazing. She listened to everything I wanted and then some. Always answered questions and if she didn’t know them she would find out for me. Easy to work with.
Aug 23, 2023

Ellen Sawyers recommends Allisia Turner

Allisia was not only totally professional she answered all questions And Pointed out items I hadn’t even thought of
She Knew the properties very well that she was showing and made sure
She had our best interest at heart
Would Definitely refer her to friends
Aug 19, 2023

Mohammad shoiab recommends Amy Fox


Amy is very helpful and good person at heart
Aug 18, 2023

Matthew Ferguson recommends Amy Fox

Unbelievable! Most honest hard working professional I have ever worked with. Amy goes above and beyond!
Aug 13, 2023

Joe recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz is the best realtor ever! I would most definitely recommend her to anyone. She was always super nice and willing to help us find the perfect house. She also treated us like her own kids which was super nice!


Our Team