913 Madison Ave.
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
WI License #48218-90
About
Share
Liz Kostroski
Real Estate Professional
Allisia Turner
Real Estate Professional
Carolyn Fox
Real Estate Professional
Amy Fox
Real Estate Professional
Tremayne McGraw
Real Estate Professional
Tonya Toth
Real Estate Professional
Rachel Lehmann
Real Estate Professional
Emily Primakow
Real Estate Professional
SM
Stefany Muehlenbruch
recommends
Tonya Toth
Jun 24, 2025
Tonya is a great Realtor. She is patient, focused, honest, dependable, and works hard for each of her clients. Thank you for helping with the sale of my late father's home.
JF
Great expereince. I would highly recommend Tremayne. I told him what I was looking for and he showed me many potentional properties. He goes the extra mile for his customers.
AR
Ann Riddle
recommends
Amy Fox
Jun 13, 2025
We recently worked with Amy on a remote home purchase. She went above and beyond to handle so many details that we couldn’t be there for. She kept us well informed and guided us through all aspects of our home buying process. We had some challenges arise after the home inspection and she was there to handle everything for us. I would absolutely recommend Amy for anyone looking for a realtor to work with.
JR
Jordan Reilly
recommends
Amy Fox
May 12, 2025
Amy was a tremendous asset in our home buying process. She was incredibly responsive, always answering messages within a few minutes. She even took calls while she was on a work trip, ensuring that all urgent manners were addressed. Her knowledge of the home buying process and current market conditions is extraordinary, and I could not speak any higher of the services that she provides.
KB
Kelly Blum
recommends
Allisia Turner
Apr 22, 2025
Allisia was so knowledgeable and professional. I've never sold a house before so I didn't know what to expect. Allisia helped me understand everything and made it so easy!
DK
Dan Kutschenreuter
recommends
Allisia Turner
Apr 18, 2025
Allisia is more than excellent to work with. Everything's done in a timely manner, she's often even 2 steps ahead. Goes above and beyond to help make things meet closing requirements. Willing to work late night or early morning depending on your personal availability. Great with kids if they are a long looking too, even brought different little toys for them each to keep everytime. 10/10 would recommend and most definitely would use Allisia for my next house.
KA
Kate and Joe Johnson
recommend
Liz Kostroski
Apr 16, 2025
We found Liz on a whim after scheduling a viewing in Fort Atkinson and it seems the universe was on our side with the pairing. After our first meeting, we immediately knew we wanted her to help us on the journey of finding a home! She is incredibly knowledgeable and is able to convey said knowledge easily to help buyers come to their own conclusion about properties. Liz was always available if we had a question or if we were interested in looking at a property. She even went as far as to assist us during her time off/vacation! In the event that Liz wasn’t available, she would send a trusted peer in her place. We were lucky enough to get advice from both Liz, and her peer Alicia, at NextHome. Both woman were great and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking into purchasing property!
SB
Scott Boie
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Apr 7, 2025
Carolyn has helped me, my family, my friends, and my friends friends for over a decade now. She is always kind and greets with a smile. She has sharp eye for details that make the difference in better sale and a vision for the future of what could be. If you are looking for an honest realtor with a great sense of humor and kindness to walk you through challenging issues - Carolyn is the Best. Thanks for helping me Carolyn.
Leenee Pafford
recommends
Tonya Toth
Mar 29, 2025
Tonya did a great good. I was so happy with her and all she had done. She was very pleasant to work with. I highly recommend her. I’ve worked with a lot of realtors in my day and she was the best I’ve ever worked with.
Anonymous
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Mar 11, 2025
Liz is awesome at what she does..she got us in our forever home with the 1st house she showed us
Robert Denruiter-green
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Mar 11, 2025
Liz showed us 1 house and we were done because she is so good at what she does .She took what we wanted and found it right away and now we own it
PG
Patty Gleitet
recommends
Allisia Turner
Mar 10, 2025
Allisia was the best! We saw several houses and many fell thru until we found our forever home. The whole experience was easy and she kept us up to date on everything.
Highly recommend her!
Highly recommend her!
KW
Kyle Wild
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Mar 3, 2025
Carolyn was fantastic to work with. She was incredibly responsive, always quick to reply to my questions, and genuinely committed to helping me find the right home. As a first time home buyer her patience, professionalism, and dedication made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!
TB
this was a smaller transaction but Carolyn did not treat it as such and she did a great job!
CL
Christine Lesniewski
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Mar 2, 2025
Carolyn helped us find our house 10 years ago, and was our selling agent also. She is very helpful, professional, and always has great advise. It was a pleasure to have her as our realtor. I will recommend her to anyone I know selling or buying in the future.
Carolyn has proved herself time and time again as a realtor and a professional. She is my one and only go to person for expert advice in the real estate market. Having multiple rental properties both buying and selling Carolyn has always came through for me. Not only is Carolyn Exceptional at her job. I also consider her my friend and value her straightforward, honest and unbiased opinion regarding the markets. Even if she does not know the answer to a question she always has someone to referral to answer that question. Carolyn has decades of experience and I would refer her or recommend her to anyone!
YM
Yvonne M Brown
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Feb 13, 2025
It took a long time but Liz helped me find my cute little dream house!
SH
When the time came that we had to find a new home, our son got us in touch with Liz. She was so amazing and now is someone we consider a friend for life. I would recommend her to anyone that is looking to sell or buy. She made me laugh and hugged me I got overwhelmed and cried and she understood the urgency of finding us a new home. We will be forever grateful for her and all her work and her friendship.
GH
Gary Hensen
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Feb 10, 2025
I was extremely impressed with her dedication to her job. After talking to her explaining our needs and wants in a house I was truly impressed on the time frame that she was able to find a selection of homes and showings we were able to see and that resulted in purchasing one. Liz made the process enjoyable and any questions I had were answered thoroughly so I could understand the process. She is a realtor that makes sure her clients understands fully the process of buying a house.
JF
Janel Frarck
recommends
Tonya Toth
Dec 27, 2024
Tonya is very personable, helpful, knowledgeable and made herself available whenever I had a question. She was engaged and focused throughout the process of selling my house; knew exactly how to price it, present it and critique the offers. She's a real Pro and I wholeheartedly recommend her!
BR
B Riedlcarlson
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Dec 27, 2024
We’ve used Liz in the past. My sister has known her and her husband for several years. She is very personable, knows her craft. Very helpful answering questions. We would highly recommend her for buying or selling property.
JK
Jameson Kammer
recommends
Tonya Toth
Dec 22, 2024
Tonya made this a super easy process. Took care of everything. Got into our new home in less than a month. Can't thank her enough for the work she did.
JD
Jennie Doering
recommends
Tonya Toth
Dec 19, 2024
Tonya was great to work with. She was kind and was quick on answering all questions. She listened to what we were looking for and helped it get it. Would recommend her to anyone I know that is looking to buy house.
TP
Tara Pinnow
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Dec 5, 2024
Liz was so beyond helpful, patient and very knowledgeable about everything. We had a lot of questions throughout the process and she always explained it perfectly and answered quickly. So grateful for her and our first home sale experience!!
TD
Tina Davis
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Nov 29, 2024
I had a really awesome experience working with Carolyn. She worked so hard to get us a very nice home. I love the amount of experience and knowledge she has. We are very happy with our new home, and so happy Carolyn was there every step of the way. Thank you so much ♡
