NextHome Success

913 Madison Ave.
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
WI License #48218-90


Recommendations (162)

Aug 29, 2023

Brett Launderville recommends Tonya Toth

She was absolutely amazing. She listened to everything I wanted and then some. Always answered questions and if she didn’t know them she would find out for me. Easy to work with.
Aug 23, 2023

Ellen Sawyers recommends Allisia Turner

Allisia was not only totally professional she answered all questions And Pointed out items I hadn’t even thought of
She Knew the properties very well that she was showing and made sure
She had our best interest at heart
Would Definitely refer her to friends
Aug 19, 2023

Mohammad shoiab recommends Amy Fox


Amy is very helpful and good person at heart
Aug 18, 2023

Matthew Ferguson recommends Amy Fox

Unbelievable! Most honest hard working professional I have ever worked with. Amy goes above and beyond!
Aug 13, 2023

Joe recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz is the best realtor ever! I would most definitely recommend her to anyone. She was always super nice and willing to help us find the perfect house. She also treated us like her own kids which was super nice!
Jul 28, 2023

Katie B. recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz has helped me buy a home twice now. She remembered me the 2nd time around. Fought hard for me every step of the way. Told mey next steps at every turn. For someone who is clueless, she made buying a home on my own so much less stressful. Hands down adore her!
Jul 27, 2023

Jim Sullivan recommends Tremayne McGraw

We couldn't have been happier through a difficult buyer's market with the way Treymane navigated us through all the ups and downs. Tremayne always kept us informed of homes on the market and set up viewings in a prompt manner around our schedule. He always said we would find our home and thanks to Tremayne we did!
We highly recommend Tremayne and NextHome.
Happy home owners,
Jim and Linda
Jul 18, 2023

Bill & Jane Wagie recommend Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne was recommended to us by a friend and he did not disappoint. He was friendly and prompt. Tremayne showed a tremendous knowledge of the current market conditions in our area. He was very helpful in pointing out a few minor updates and improvements to help increase interest and value of our property.
Tremayne always responded to our questions very quickly and kept us updated with any new information. I can not think of anything more you could ask for when looking for someone to sell or find a home.
Jul 14, 2023

Adrianna Ellefson recommends Allisia Turner

Great person, she explained the process and timeline of closing to me, and made sure I understood what was going on. She checked in at key times and asked if I needed help.
Jun 20, 2023

Carolee Holtan recommends Liz Kostroski

Liz was simply awesome! She listened to our needs and wants, understood budget concerns and always available for questions.

Worked around our crazy schedule to show us only houses that would be good fit for us.

If you want someone that steps into your shoes when viewing a home with you, then Liz is the realtor to gently guide you into your new home.

May 29, 2023

Anonymous recommends Liz Kostroski

We hired Liz to sell our not-so-typical property. She helped us navigate the market place and she handled the offers with professionalism. We were very pleased with the outcome!
May 19, 2023

Maria Altmayer recommends Allisia Turner

Allisia was so very helpful in our real estate transaction. Provided lots of information with different accounts that needed to be changed. She was very flexible with meeting times and was so prompt responding to e-mails. THE BEST!
May 5, 2023

Bill Davis recommends Tonya Toth

Ive worked with Tanya for some time now and her knowledgeable service
has been great.
Bill Davis
May 2, 2023

Jill Dahnert recommends Liz Kostroski

Daughter of home owner

I highly recommend Liz...from beginning to end she made my mom feel comfortable and never an elderly woman selling your home...that was very important to us for our mom!! It really was a fast, easy process!! Thank You Liz
Apr 27, 2023

Tim Dougherty recommends Carolyn Fox


Great with negotiating and follow through. Worked with her for over a decade and have sold many properties with her! Wouldn't use anyone else!

If want it to get done give it to Carolyn and her team!
Apr 1, 2023

Hank Neils recommends Liz Kostroski

Sales Representative

Liz was very professional in your approach. She set our asking price in an accurate manner and knows the local market well. We were able to secure our asking price within 4 days of hitting the open market. We would highly recommend Liz.
Mar 10, 2023

Greggory Patrick recommends Carolyn Fox

I have known Carolyn since before she got into real estate and have done business with her/her team ever since. Reason is Carolyn is a true professional that is efficient, effective and accessable. Couldn't ask for more. Carolyn is the best! Highly recommended.
Feb 16, 2023

Dianna wolff recommends Allisia Turner

Allsia was wonderful and let me know what was going on and answered all my questions. It was wonderful working with her.
Jan 30, 2023

Ben Swenarski recommends Tonya Toth

Looking to buy my first house Tonya was very helpful with the process and made it simple. She explained the process in a way anyone can understand. She was also quick to respond to any questions I had over text or email.
Jan 10, 2023

Sharon Bishop recommends Carolyn Fox


Carolyn Fox most professional real estate person I have met and I am old. She gets the job done and done correctly. This is the 3rd time I have tried to write this recommendation, Why do you keep sending me this?
Dec 26, 2022

Justin Andersen recommends Liz Kostroski

Truck driver

Liz is amazing seeing that I’m a OTR truck driver she did all the work and all I had to do is sign papers highly recommend her if your buying or selling property
Dec 19, 2022

JONATHAN SANDERSON recommends Tremayne McGraw

Tremayne, did what seemed to be the impossible. We listed our mobile home in early October and sold by early December. He always kept us in the loop with viewers, gave an honest assessment of the status of our progress in regards to selling, and was always available for calls and text messages. After our closing, we had relocated to temporary location. He priority mailed our check to us and messaged the tracking number till the check arrived. If you want to sell your home fast and work with someone with great work ethic Tremayne is the guy for you.
Dec 2, 2022

Justin Andersen recommends Liz Kostroski


If I could give her more stars I would she goes above and beyond highly recommend anyone buying or selling a house to check her out you won’t regret it ??
Nov 11, 2022

Glenn Rollins recommends Liz Kostroski

Searching for a new home from a state away is a challenge. Liz took into consideration how difficult that was and helped us negotiate that issue. As we had a health issue two days before the move, Liz helped immeasurably as we had to reschedule the closing and the move. She gets the challenges of moving and under such difficult conditions, stepped up to help us in more ways because of those moving challenges!
Nov 7, 2022

Andrew Zastrow recommends Liz Kostroski

If I had to rate Liz 1-5 Id give her a 10! I ran into many problems in the homebuying process and she was there helping me every step of the way. Keeping in contact with me, the seller, my lender, and various possible contractors to assist me. I can't express how much of a help she was with my homebuyer journey.

I highly recommend her for anyone that is looking to buy!!


Our Team