913 Madison Ave.
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
WI License #48218-90
About
Share
Liz Kostroski
Real Estate Professional
Allisia Turner
Real Estate Professional
Carolyn Fox
Real Estate Professional
Tremayne McGraw
Real Estate Professional
Amy Fox
Real Estate Professional
Tonya Toth
Real Estate Professional
Rachel Lehmann
Real Estate Professional
MP
Michael probst
recommends
Tremayne McGraw
Oct 10, 2025
Tremayne did great finding a buyer for the house and was very helpful and patient with me while I got everything completed before the sale
OJ
Oma Jean dixon
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Oct 10, 2025
Carolyn did a marvelous job helping us sell our house. She understood our special needs (age/disabilities) and found us the perfect buyer even before we listed the home. Professional dedicated and caring real estate agent. Her experience and knowledge of the ends and outs of buying and selling homes shows. I would definitely recommend Carolyn Fox
SB
Shellie Biegemann
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Oct 9, 2025
We had the pleasure of working with Liz Kostroski from NextHome in Jefferson County, WI to sell our rental property—and we couldn't be more thankful. Liz is not only a trusted friend, but also an amazing realtor who brings honesty, loyalty, and a true passion for her work.
Her professionalism and market knowledge made the entire process feel seamless. She communicated clearly, answered all our questions, and guided us through each step with confidence and care. Liz truly went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled perfectly.
If you're looking for someone who is both personable and highly skilled, Liz is the one to call. She made a potentially stressful experience feel easy, and we’re incredibly grateful for her dedication.
Scott and Shellie Biegemann
Her professionalism and market knowledge made the entire process feel seamless. She communicated clearly, answered all our questions, and guided us through each step with confidence and care. Liz truly went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled perfectly.
If you're looking for someone who is both personable and highly skilled, Liz is the one to call. She made a potentially stressful experience feel easy, and we’re incredibly grateful for her dedication.
Scott and Shellie Biegemann
EH
Eldgret Howard jr
recommends
Tremayne McGraw
Oct 7, 2025
Excellent realtor, answered any questions , quick response, also quick to tell you new listing, available for showings any time and day
KJ
Karen J.
recommends
Rachel Lehmann
Oct 4, 2025
We were so happy to work with Rachel and all of the great results and support she was able to provide. We were selling a family home from out of state and Rachel could not have been more patient or helpful. Plus we received multiple offers and had a great closing! Thank you Rachel.
GB
Excellent work. Easy to work with. Incredibly responsive. Great advice and help throughout the process
IG
Ian Gillitzer
recommends
Rachel Lehmann
Sep 29, 2025
Rachel was awesome every step of the way through out the whole process. Would recommend her to everyone that I know truly was a great experience!
JK
Jill Kroeger
recommends
Rachel Lehmann
Sep 27, 2025
Rachel sold our parents condo with ease and took the reins in a difficult time in our lives. She made the process easy and flawless with a quick closing and a good price. I would recommend her to use as a realtor.
GW
Gwen Wohlgefahrt
recommends
Rachel Lehmann
Sep 26, 2025
Rachel had great communication and was very accommodating in all areas to make sure the sale went through smoothly.
GL
He did à great job covering all aspects of this home buying. He showed great patience with the jerking around we got from from the buyers of the house I had in Maine. Would strongly recomend him to anyone else looking to buy à home. He knows his stuff.
TW
We couldn’t have asked for a better real estate agent. Tremayne was exceptionally knowledgeable, communicative, and supportive throughout the entire process. We would confidently recommend him to anyone seeking a reliable and dedicated agent. Truly an outstanding experience.
BK
Tonya and NextHome did a really great job selling my house. They have great teamwork to complete the sale. Tonya worked especially hard trying to sell my house. We had some trouble spots and she really stepped up to solve any problems to move the selling forward with buyers. I appreciate all the time and efforts they put forward to help me complete the sale of my house. Thank you!!
ME
Michael Eggert
recommends
Tonya Toth
Jul 31, 2025
Tonya was absolutely wonderful to deal with! She was kind, and thoughtful. She was very detailed when showing us the mobile home. She was always available to answer questions anytime day or night! She was always quick to get back to you. She was very patient and easy to talk to. I would definitely recommend her for your buying and selling needs. We will definitely be keeping her in mind for future real-estate business!
KT
Kaiyli Thompson
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Jul 31, 2025
I couldn’t have asked for a better relator. She was so kind and patient throughout the whole process. She made us feel comfortable and was so accommodating to our busy schedules. She was also a huge advocate for us and I can’t thank her enough!
BW
Liz was the best person we could have asked to help find a house. She was very motherly and made us feel very comfortable to communicate with. She answered the phone or called us within minutes of reaching out if there was a problem or anything to discuss and helped us learn about the home purchasing process!
CH
Christa Hnilicka
recommends
Liz Kostroski
Jul 21, 2025
Liz is always a pleasure to work with. She cares about her clients and treats them like family. She is very knowledgeable in her field and makes herself readily available for showings, to answer questions, or whatever else you may need. Liz is very trustworthy and invested in wanting to help her clients find the perfect fit. I would highly recommend Liz for any of your realty needs!
SM
Stefany Muehlenbruch
recommends
Tonya Toth
Jun 24, 2025
Tonya is a great Realtor. She is patient, focused, honest, dependable, and works hard for each of her clients. Thank you for helping with the sale of my late father's home.
JF
Great expereince. I would highly recommend Tremayne. I told him what I was looking for and he showed me many potentional properties. He goes the extra mile for his customers.
AR
Ann Riddle
recommends
Amy Fox
Jun 13, 2025
We recently worked with Amy on a remote home purchase. She went above and beyond to handle so many details that we couldn’t be there for. She kept us well informed and guided us through all aspects of our home buying process. We had some challenges arise after the home inspection and she was there to handle everything for us. I would absolutely recommend Amy for anyone looking for a realtor to work with.
JR
Jordan Reilly
recommends
Amy Fox
May 12, 2025
Amy was a tremendous asset in our home buying process. She was incredibly responsive, always answering messages within a few minutes. She even took calls while she was on a work trip, ensuring that all urgent manners were addressed. Her knowledge of the home buying process and current market conditions is extraordinary, and I could not speak any higher of the services that she provides.
KB
Kelly Blum
recommends
Allisia Turner
Apr 22, 2025
Allisia was so knowledgeable and professional. I've never sold a house before so I didn't know what to expect. Allisia helped me understand everything and made it so easy!
DK
Dan Kutschenreuter
recommends
Allisia Turner
Apr 18, 2025
Allisia is more than excellent to work with. Everything's done in a timely manner, she's often even 2 steps ahead. Goes above and beyond to help make things meet closing requirements. Willing to work late night or early morning depending on your personal availability. Great with kids if they are a long looking too, even brought different little toys for them each to keep everytime. 10/10 would recommend and most definitely would use Allisia for my next house.
KA
Kate and Joe Johnson
recommend
Liz Kostroski
Apr 16, 2025
We found Liz on a whim after scheduling a viewing in Fort Atkinson and it seems the universe was on our side with the pairing. After our first meeting, we immediately knew we wanted her to help us on the journey of finding a home! She is incredibly knowledgeable and is able to convey said knowledge easily to help buyers come to their own conclusion about properties. Liz was always available if we had a question or if we were interested in looking at a property. She even went as far as to assist us during her time off/vacation! In the event that Liz wasn’t available, she would send a trusted peer in her place. We were lucky enough to get advice from both Liz, and her peer Alicia, at NextHome. Both woman were great and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking into purchasing property!
SB
Scott Boie
recommends
Carolyn Fox
Apr 7, 2025
Carolyn has helped me, my family, my friends, and my friends friends for over a decade now. She is always kind and greets with a smile. She has sharp eye for details that make the difference in better sale and a vision for the future of what could be. If you are looking for an honest realtor with a great sense of humor and kindness to walk you through challenging issues - Carolyn is the Best. Thanks for helping me Carolyn.
Leenee Pafford
recommends
Tonya Toth
Mar 29, 2025
Tonya did a great good. I was so happy with her and all she had done. She was very pleasant to work with. I highly recommend her. I’ve worked with a lot of realtors in my day and she was the best I’ve ever worked with.
