Keith Fenner

Sr. Mortgage Loan Officer Spire Financial NMLS: 804718
Born and raised in beautiful Colorado! For all of the latest market news and mortgage information, give me a call! I am available anytime to speak with you and answer your home buying or refinancing questions.
Nov 10, 2020
Amazing support and would recommend to anyone!
Oct 23, 2020
It was wonderful working with Keith. As a first time homebuyer, Keith explained all the ins and outs of the purchasing process. He helped make this process easier and more enjoyable.
Oct 12, 2020
Director of Leadership Giving
Keith Fenner made the mortgage lending process streamlined and easy for the second time in my home buying journey! He is attentive during the entire process and works will you on achieving your property goals.
Sep 22, 2020
I had the pleasure of working with Keith and his team to purchase my first home. They were awesome! Throughout the entire process, Keith was available at anytime to address any questions or concerns.

I highly recommend Keith and his team to help get you in your new home.
Sep 19, 2020
Keith was easy to work with and always very responsive. I will definitely give Keith a call the next time I need mortgage lending needs.
May 2, 2020
Account Manager
Keith helped make my home refinance seamless! He made me feel very at ease with my decision and I would recommend him to anyone. Thank you Keith for a wonderful experience!
Apr 27, 2020
Keith has been an amazing agent. We’ve worked with him on a few refinances. He is very professional, knowledgeable, and thorough. He is always available to answer questions & clear up details. We would recommend Keith every time and look forward to continue working with him!
Oct 22, 2019
Commercial Sales
Keith did a phenomenal job working to get me the best possible home loan available. As a first time home buyer I was very nervous for this stage of the home buying process. With Keith’s patience and expertise he was able to walk me through every step of the way. An awesome experience and I highly recommend Keith for any home buying assistance.
Aug 15, 2019
Keith Fenner and his team did an excellent job of sorting through the available financing products and helping us select the best option for our needs. He was always available to discuss, prompt in returning our inquiries, and an overall pleasure to work with through the home buying process. Highly recommend.

Aug 13, 2019
CEO BriteStreet Energy Group
Keith was a pleasure to work with. Throughout the process he kept me informed and completed the loan faster than I could have expected. Keith and his team were very professional. I will recommend them to everyone.
May 22, 2019
My fiancé and I recently bought a house and were referred to use Keith through a friend. We live in Ft. Collins and despite the distance we thought it would be worth it to use someone with a good recommendation, and I am so glad we did. We were caught in a bidding war and Keith (on his own) called the listing agent and spoke with her about our loan and us. I believe it was this step that actually won us the house. The seller's realtor was so impressed with Keith that she listed this as one of the reasons she advised the seller to go with us. He was so helpful through the whole process and explained everything to us so well. We are first time home buyers and often became overwhelmed and forgot information but Keith was patient and informative throughout. He was also so responsive, whenever we had a question he responded almost immediately. I couldn't have been more impressed and happy with all the help he provided. I have recommended him to everyone I know and will continue to do so!
May 6, 2019
We worked with Keith when we bought our house, and again when we refinanced our mortgage. He and his team clearly walk you through what needs to be done throughout the process, and are very responsive to answer any questions that come up. The great communication makes for an easy, stress free loan application. I would highly recommend Keith to anyone looking to buy or refinance.
Apr 16, 2019
Home Owner
Keith was terrific! I was new to the CO area and real estate scene, and he helped me understand the process, pricing, etc. He was great at following up, and making sure that I was covered if he was not available. He was quick on responses, and I would definitely recommend him! Thanks Keith!!!
Oct 16, 2018
Keith Fenner was great to work with. He took the time to explain the process and was very professional.
May 4, 2018
Keith was absolutely exceptional to work with. No matter the time of day or night he was always answering my emails or text. He was always willing to answer my questions, no matter how many I had. I would recommend Keith to anyone!
Jul 11, 2017
Keith did a great assisting in the financing of our new home. He was very thorough and followed up often. It was a very easy process and will recommend him to everyone we know. Thank you Keith!
Apr 7, 2017
US Sales Representative
Keith and the AmeriFirst team has taken care of me from my original loan through two refinances. Keith has gone above and beyond on each transaction. I highly recommend calling Keith first if even considering a first loan or refinance. The process is always smooth and easy.
Mar 20, 2017
Business Analyst
Keith was great to work with. He was professional, responsive and efficient. Keith would respond to any question, regardless of the time or day. No detail was ignored and he was able to get us through the loan process in less than 30 days. Keith made it an extremely easy process. I highly recommend working with Keith.
Dec 29, 2016
Product Manager
We were so lucky to get Keith as our Loan Officer. He helped us every step of the way in a very confusing and overwhelming process. Keith took his time to explain everything we needed to know and we didn't feel pressured to jump into anything. He made everything easy, from the application process, the approval process, and he even came to our closing! I would highly recommend Keith to anyone who is looking for a loan to buy a home. You can have confidence that he will get you the best rate and is there to help every step of the way!
Dec 23, 2016
Keith did a great job for us, on an initial loan and a subsequent refinance. I highly recommend him.
Oct 18, 2016
I met Keith when we refinanced our house via a real estate agent, Tyler.

For very busy people like my husband and I, Keith was very easy to work with and extremly flexible in schedule. He is very fast and very prompt to respond to all questions you may have. He is proactive looking for you until he finds you to rapidly finalize the financing. In our case, he also has been extremly helpful when refinancing our house the second time under very advantageous conditons. I have to say that refinancing the second time was Keith's his ideea when the rate went down.
Oct 14, 2016
We have used Keith on 3 separate mortgages/refinances. He is great to work with, very efficient and has made the process quick and painless.
Oct 8, 2016
Keith and his staff were amazing throughout the purchase of our home. He was knowledgeable, efficient and closed on time! We were impressed and absolutely recommend Keith for any purchase or refinance needs.

My Associations