Clicky

Michelle Garagiola

49 Recommendations
About Me
Real Estate Professional NextHome Realty Premier Properties

2380 Route 9 S, Bldg C, Unit 4
Howell, NJ 07731
NJ License #1643876

Vincent Carnevale
Senior Loan Officer Advisors Mortgage Group, LLC
Pinned Recommendation
AP
Nursing Director Jan 9, 2025
From my first meeting with Michelle and through the entire process of being in charge of my families estate, she made me feel at ease with her professional expertise along with her genuine and caring nature. Selling a family home along with mourning your loved one is an over whelming emotional roller-coaster. Michelle was always available in every capacity to ensure every step was being executed as smoothly as possible. Her hard work and dedication is impeccable and admiring! She went above and beyond and was always prompt for everything and anything. I feel so blessed to have gained another sister and friend in this journey. There are not enough words to express how truly thankful I am that I had her by my side every step of the way! From day one she advised "Please don't worry, there's a house for everyone and the day will come when it's meant to be" Those words stayed with me every time I needed a pick me up. That day did come and it was meant to be for the new family. Forever grateful for Michelle and her team during a bittersweet time for my family. Highly recommend and will definitely be in touch for future transactions together.
DD
Apr 22, 2025
Michelle is the best. She's so easy to work with, kind, and caring but also a straightforward and no nonsense advocate when working with other agents. She has been our family's seller's agent three times (two as estate sales) and buyer's agent once. The properties she sold for us were all unique and required her sustained effort over several months each time to find the right buyer. She was immediately responsive every time and kept on top of everything and made sure the transactions went smoothly. Her knowledge helped us avoid mistakes and price the properties correctly to maximize showings and financial return. She's a tenacious negotiator as well. We would never use anyone but Michelle for real estate transactions.
PM
New Homeowner Nov 8, 2024
Michelle was a true partner in my home search and purchase. She is an exceptionally ethical, skilled, empathetic and communicative broker. She always kept my requirements as her first priority and acted as an advocate and informed resource at every step of the process. Her referrals for financing, legal and inspection resources were top notch and saved me the time of locating and vetting my own. Michelle has solid negotiation skills and looked to find the best compromise wherever possible. I am thrilled with the result of her efforts and truly happy and satisfied in my new home. I recommend her as a Seller's Broker with absolutely no reservations. If you're looking for a true partner in your home search and purchase, Michelle is the broker for you!
BW
Jan 1, 2024
We cannot express enough how grateful we are for Michelle. She made the process of selling our home so smooth and simple. She was extremely responsive, knowledgeable, and professional. She went above and beyond for us and really made sure we stayed informed and updated. We always felt like she had our best interests and concerns at the forefront of negotiations and ultimately we closed on an offer above asking price. We highly recommend Michelle and if we’re ever looking to buy or sell in NJ again, we know who we will be using as our realtor!
TC
Feb 10, 2022
As first time home buyers, my fiancé and I had many questions and concerns. Michelle quickly alleviated alot of our stress by maintaining contact with us and displaying such a positive and authentic outlook. Michelle is personable, friendly, and gets the job done! I highly recommend seeking Michelle's assistance with any future home buying. My fiancé and I are so happy in our first home and it is all becuase of Michelle's hard work and dedication.
JR
Aug 5, 2021
I do not have enough words to express how grateful I am to have met and worked with Michelle. She has been a game changer in helping us secure our forever home. She has been patient, knowledgeable, and kind throughout our whole home buying and selling processes. She willingly spent her weekends touring homes with us, guiding through making offers to the point where we found and bought the home of our dreams. Her expertise and planning also allowed us to sell our home within 3 days. Her help and support has been invaluable. I’ve worked with several agents in my life and Michelle is special - she puts “humans before homes” as she says and she totally means it. This is someone who not only proudly represents you, but Michelle is someone I am now proud to consider a friend. I could not have gotten through this without Michelle, her help, her recommendations, and her care. Simply amazing!
MM
Sep 13, 2020
Michelle is outstanding! We recently needed to sell our home in NJ for an out of state move. Our home was beautifully marketed and sold within the first week. Michelle is professional, always accessible, extremely knowledgeable, kind, and easy to talk to. She protected us and guided us so that we never experienced any stress. Thank you Michelle for such a great experience!